Oral Argument – Preparation and Participation Rubric
Group Members/Role:
|
Judges’ Rubric:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Preparation:
1. Group members used preparation time well.
2. All documents and precedents were examined and considered.
3. Group work was well-organized and work was evenly distributed.
4. Notes and potential questions.
|
1
1
1
1 |
2
2
2
2 |
3
3
3
3 |
4
4
4
4 |
5
5
5
5 |
|
Questions to Attorneys:
1. Questions are logical and thoughtful.
2. Information from and references to documents and Precedents are used in questioning.
3. All group members contribute/participate in questioning.
4. Questions relate to issues raised by each side.
|
1
1
1
1 |
2
2
2
2 |
3
3
3
3 |
4
4
4
4 |
5
5
5
5 |
|
Presentation of Decision:
1. Decision is thoughtful.
2. Decision is concise. |
1
1 |
2
2 |
3
3 |
4
4 |
5
5 |